ARW Pre-PWT

Human cloning should not be allowed in Japan for two reasons: mental harm and violation of human right.
Even if the risk of physical is 100% sure, it harms mental of cloned humans. For example, people support human cloning often say that it can help people who lost their children. It can save parents sorrow, however, the cloned child will be lived as a "substitute." It means the cloned child is not respected as a single individual. It is not the only case of harming a clone child. Whatever is the situation, in the background of a cloned human, there is always existence of another person who has same gene. And it will be a obstacle in the process of forming individual and identity.
Second, human cloning have a danger of violating human right. The word "clone" divides who is a clone and who is not a clone. This classification will lead to discrimination even if people are not intend to. And human clones are not treated same as other "normal human" when a discrimination happens. In the Constitution of Japan, the right to live is assured. Even human clones have same gene as others. However, they are a human. They have a right to live as a single human and right to be treated as other people. However, human perception can't be changed easily. And unfortunately, there are not only good men. There are people who discriminates other people. In fact, even the notion of equality of human has been prevailed in Japan, there are a lot of human who discriminate Korean residents. Therefore, human cloning will lead to discriminate human clones and violating their rights.
Human cloning has a risk of harming mental of people who are cloned. Cloned people will suffer own identity and the meaning of own existence. In addition, human cloning has the possibility to violate the right to live of cloned human, because they will be discriminated by people who are not cloned. For this two reasons, the human cloning shoul not be allowed in Japan.



It is hard to make persuasive: (
It is easy to say "it violates human right", but it is hard to explain how violating right.
Bioethic is very complex issue so I'm afraid whether I can write a short essay without using dictionary...!